Author: Anne McCaffrey
Series: Harper Hall Trilogy #1
Rating: 4.5/5 stars
The Overview: Every two hundred years or so, shimmering threads fall, raining black ruin on Pern. The great dragons of Pern hurl themselves through the beleaguered skies, flaming tongues of fire to destroy deadly Thread and save the planet. It was not Threadfall that made Menolly unhappy. It was her father who betrayed her ambition to be a Harper, who thwarted her love of music. Menolly had no choice but to run away. She came upon a group of fire lizards, wild relatives of the fire-breathing dragons. Her music swirled about them; she taught nine to sing, suddenly Menolly was no longer alone.
This is going to be a fairly short review for a really great dragon book. I don’t know that I can honestly claim to have a Dragon Obsession with out having read at least a few McCafferys (although I’d like to note I eventually plan on reading all them). Even though Dragonsong is only the first book of the Harper Hall Trilogy, I can already tell it’s going to be just as good as the original Dragonriders of Pern series.
As with Pern, I initially had trouble getting into the flow of the story because of the writing style – it’s not exactly what I would call accessible. McCaffrey uses a rather high-brow language that can sometimes make you feel as if you’re trying to read a textbook. While I think the more readers you can retain with your writing the better, this particular writing style is part of what makes these books unique, so they get a lot of allowances where other books might not. I only had a difficult time focusing at the beginning of the book, but once I settled into the flow of the language, the story came alive.
I absolutely love Dragonsong’s storyline – it’s about a teenaged girl who accidentally enthralls a bunch of fire lizards with her remarkable music. The main character, Mellony, was as charming as she was atypical. She is not a petite, helpless little waif but a tall, strong, capable young woman who knows what she wants out of life (even though she doesn’t always get it). I found her incredibly likable because of how humble, hard-working, compassionate she was – I can totally see why the fire lizards were drawn to her.
I liked this story so much that I’m kind of kicking myself for not continuing on straight away. I’m eager to see where Mellony’s story takes her next and am secretly hoping for some sort of love story to develop. Overall, if you like McCaffery (or dragons in general) I think you’ll enjoy Dragonsong. It takes place chronologically after Dragonquest of the Dragonriders of Pern series, but right before The White Dragon, so you may at the very least want to read the first two of that trilogy to avoid spoilers. In trying to figure out what order to read the books in, I found the lists on this website very helpful.
Other books you might like:
I loooove this book! It is my fave book of McAffrey’s. I’m a musician, so I identified very strongly with the main character. I like some of McAffrey’s other dragon books, but the Harper Hall books are my absolute fave.
Great review! Can’t wait to see what you think of the rest of the trilogy.
OMG!! I just found a couple of your comments in my SPAM box from 2014?! O_o. Holy moly! Anyway, if you are still in the blogosphere, I want to say thanks for your comments and I totally wish I had seen this 2 years ago. :P
LikeLiked by 1 person
And I have been holding my breath for two years, WAITING for your reply! Haha! Just kidding. Now you owe me two comments. And I’ll check my spam to be sure! 😉
HAhaha! Deal ;)
LikeLiked by 1 person
That list is awesome – there are so many series within series where Pern is concerned! This book was definitely up there with the first Dragonriders book for me. And the second one is also fantastic! …sadly the third book rather derails. But if there’s like 50 books in a series, they can’t ALL be the best!
I’m at work so I’m in a different log in, but this is Elizabeth from so long and thanks for all the fish!